Bureaucrats, Check users, Interface administrators, Administrators (Semantic MediaWiki), Administrators, vuser
9,362
edits
Changes
Talk:Criticism of crowdsourcing (view source)
Revision as of 19:34, 10 October 2008
, 19:34, 10 October 2008Selina's opinion
[[User:Geoff Wilson|Geoff Wilson]] 11:09, 10 October 2008 (PDT)
[[User:Geoff Wilson|Geoff Wilson]] 11:09, 10 October 2008 (PDT)
== Selina's opinion ==
Not trying to stir up drama. Just holding this temporarily here, in case it gets oversighted from Wikipedia Review.
QUOTE(One @ Fri 10th October 2008, 6:48pm)
Yeah, I guess I'm a snob. I don't like it when site leadership chase off the best members of a community.
"best" your opinion, and I did not "chase him off", he ran off in a huff because I dared to insult him back. He's one of those people that gives it all the time but when someone stands up to him he gets all upset and offended that someone even would (I've talked with other people who said similar about thekohser but didn't say in public because of the drama factor).
QUOTE(One @ Fri 10th October 2008, 6:48pm)
My attitude is that Kohs is one of the most constructive users to this site, by any metric. Whether you care about hard meta criticism, or even the drama. He's tops.
That's pretty laughable, there was a couple of good things but primarily he was concentrated on promoting his 1-man-band business (constantly, incessantly) and posting reams of crap about how unjust it is that he isn't allowed to spam Wikipedia and that he should be unbanned. He didn't want to criticise it too much because his intention was always to become a Wikipedian again.
QUOTE(One @ Fri 10th October 2008, 6:48pm)
And he was kicked off the forum[/url]Totally irrelevant http://wikipediareview.com/index.php?showforum=10 considering he wasn't even ON the forum when his account was temporarily closed for about half an hour. He doesn't have any intention of returning either, so banned or unbanned it's a bit pointless either way.
QUOTE(One @ Fri 10th October 2008, 6:48pm)
Have you read Selina?
"? That's the facts..."
"*grin*"
"yeah well said."
"Tell us another one!"
"ooooo harsh! "
Taking quotes out of context is a cheap trick that anyone can do, a line in a conversation that people are posting to fast is perfectly acceptable I think...
QUOTE(One @ Fri 10th October 2008, 7:11pm)
I've criticized this site for not being tough enough on members. (Namely, conspiracy theorists that tend to discredit the place.)
Obviously I guess that excludes less convenient-to-criticise conspiracy theories like "Selina is poetwhatever" "Selina is telling the admins what to do on wikipedia argh shes turning them all against me!"